Peanut Butter and Jelly Earrings

A childhood favorite, but make it earrings. These handmade Peanut Butter & Jelly earrings feature a mismatched PB&J toast design with one peanut butter slice and one grape jelly slice, all sculpted from polymer clay. Lightweight, nostalgic, and full of quirky charm, they’re the perfect food earrings for snack lovers, lunchbox nostalgia, and anyone who loves fun handmade jewelry.

No piercings? No problem! A clip-on option is available! Just add the clip-on findings listing to your cart for a comfortable, non-pierced alternative.